top of page

The Second Place Sister, Part 18

Cindy from The Second Place Sister by Tori Hamlin

Chapter Forty: My Slutty Girlfriend

Over dinner that evening, Cindy regaled John and Melanie with the tale of their adventure to the mall. The little redhead prattled on excitedly, completely naked except for the leash and collar, which she refused to take off. She told them all about how great the sunshine was. She hadn’t been outside in months, after all. She talked at length about all the men staring at her in her little skirt, and how she was such a stupid slut that she’d made Stephanie buy her this leash to keep her in check.

She related the story of how a man had put his hand up her skirt, and she’d kissed him, and how a fight had almost broken out. That led to a story about the two college boys, and how they’d defended her honor (as if she had any, she jested). Tori looked very uncomfortable as Cindy got to the part about the store, in which she’d been fucked by Kyle against the wall of the dressing room.

Thankfully, Cindy dropped her fork just as she was coming to this part. The little redhead ducked under the table, found her fork, but then became distracted by Stephanie’s exposed pussy winking from beneath her skirt. Stephanie jumped when she felt Cindy’s tongue brush against her slit. John and Melanie looked at her curiously, until she began to moan with delight, and squirm in her chair.

They were utterly without words, watching Stephanie get eaten out at the dinner table. Melanie’s hand found her way into John’s lap, rubbing his bulge. She couldn’t blame him for getting turned on. Cindy had the same effect on her, as well. They tried to engage Tori in conversation, but she wasn’t really in the mood. The plug in her ass made her squirm uncomfortably in her chair. Next to her, Stephanie came loudly, and a moment later Cindy emerged from beneath the table.

“I found my fork!” She crooned happily.

“That’s great, sweetie,” Melanie said, stifling a giggle.

“I think I’m going to go to bed,” Tori said, “I’m really tired.”

“Alright, baby,” Melanie said, “do you need anything?”

“I’ll be okay,” Tori said, forcing a smile.

“Night, Tori!” Cindy called.

Tori waved to her, and went up to her room. The plug in her ass was driving her crazy. Her pussy was itching and needy, and the fullness in her bottom seemed to have pushed her just to the edge of an unattainable orgasm. She was so frustrated, and really wanted to be fucked again. She lay on her bed and tried to go to sleep, instead, but her pussy wouldn’t let her. She needed to cum! Stephanie had placed the big black dildo on her nightstand after fucking her ass with it earlier, and when she saw it laying there, she knew that there was something she could do to cum. It would mean admitting that she was a butt slut, but she could cum and go to sleep. She reached for the dildo.

Cindy was helping Stephanie clean up the remains of dinner when Mike came home a while later. Cindy squealed with joy and ran into his arms, planting kisses all over his face, and pushing her tongue in his mouth.

“Oh, baby!” She cried, “I’m so glad you’re here!”

“Hey cutie,” Mike said, grinning, “Nice to see you, too!”

“Hey, bro,” Stephanie called from the kitchen, “Will you please go put your dick up that slut? The only thing out of her mouth today has been Mike’s big cock.”

Cindy blushed, saying, “Well, that’s not exactly true! I also licked both your sister’s cunts, and you know what? They taste the same! Isn’t that weird?”

“Um, well, I guess that is...kind...of...weird...Can I get a shower first?”

“Oh, but I love the way you stink!”

“Yeah, well I don’t. You help Stephie, and I’ll be out in a minute, alright?”

“Oh, I guess! If you insist upon denying me!” Cindy said dramatically.

“Soon, soon!” Mike said, prying her lips off of his face again, “Hey, wait! What’s with the leash?”

“Oh, well, we went to the mall and went shopping, and because I’m such a stupid slut, and I get distracted really easy, I thought that maybe Stephanie should put me on a leash so she could keep me from wandering off!”

“This was your idea?”

“Yes! Aren’t I a smarty? Well, not like you, college boy, I’ve got slut smarts! Oh, yeah! Give me my Heisman!”


“The award they give to really smart people, silly!”

“Oh, yeah. You had a great idea,” Mike said, “Now get your cute little butt in there and help Stephie, will you?”


He watched her butt sway happily back into the kitchen, thinking of putting his cock in it. She was some kind of woman! He went into his cave and hit the shower.

By the time he was out and wrapped in a towel, Cindy was laying on his bed with the lights down low. Red stockings covered her legs, and she still wore the pink collar, but otherwise she was naked. Mike was already hardening at the sight of her. She was incredible, oozing sexual energy, her big eyes dancing with playful lust. She smiled when she saw him, and slithered toward the edge of the bed.

Mike dropped his towel, and Cindy gasped at his perfect cock. She’d already decided that there was no better dick in the world. It was big, but not a monster, thick, and it stayed hard constantly. If she had been asked to build the ultimate pleasure tool, it would be this cock swinging right in front of her. She wrapped her han