top of page

The Second Place Sister, Part 17

Chapter Thirty-Nine: The Butt Slut

Tori Hamlin The Second Place Sister

When they arrived home, Stephanie had been quick to get her sister’s cunt locked up again, and as she made Tori lick out her sweaty pussy, she’d berated her for her behavior.

“I accept the blame for today, Tori,” Stephanie said, pushing her sister’s face into her steaming snatch, “I let you go out without your belt on, and look what happened. You got fucked in your mouth, your pussy, and up your ass. What’s worse, is that you played with your dirty little cunt while you let that guy fuck your mouth.”

Tori worked at Stephanie’s pussy like a good cunt sucker, her own sluthole growing more aroused as Stephanie reminded her what a tramp she’d been.

“The next time, we’ll make sure you keep your belt on, and we won’t have to worry about you playing with your snatch, okay?”

Tori hummed her assent into Stephanie’s pussy as her sister came on her face. Tori happily drank down her fuck honey, as her little locked-up box got even hotter. Stephanie pushed Tori’s hungry mouth away gently, and began kissing her.

“Are you my pussy girl, baby?” she asked, looking into Tori’s wild eyes.

It was clear that getting that dick shoved in her holes had done something to her sister today, awakened some carnal urge that had finally pushed her from reluctant slut, to mildly willing slut. In fact, Tori kneeling on her floor right now wasn’t even at Stephanie’s request. They’d been going through their bounty from the mall trip, when Stephanie laid on the bed to get off her feet. Before she knew it, Tori was between her legs, licking at her slit.

“Yes, Stephie,” Tori said, “I’m your pussy girl.”

“That’s right, baby. I’ll bet you want to cum now, don’t you?”

“Yes, please!”

“Well, don’t worry. Your sister knows you’ve got a horny cunt, so I got a few more things at that store where I bought the collar.”

Tori waited on her knees. Stephanie was pleased. She hadn’t even asked. Tori just assumed that she needed to stay there until she was told otherwise. Stephanie rifled through the sacks on the bed until she found the white one from the adult novelty shop. She motioned Tori up on the bed, and made her lie on her stomach. Tori figured her sister was going to unbuckle her belt.

She watched Stephanie pull a big black dildo out of the bag, and then something else that looked like a little pyramid-shaped thing. Stephanie laid the toys on the bed, and pulled Tori’s hips up, so that her ass stuck in the air. Then, she felt her sister’s tongue on her asshole. Tori groaned as Stephanie licked at her ass, spit in her asshole, and slowly worked her finger into her bottom.

“You know,” Stephanie said, her voice husky with excitement, “I noticed something today, when that guy had his dick up your ass,” she punctuated the statement by adding a second finger to Tori’s asshole, making her moan and grip the sheets, “I noticed that you came really hard. You did, didn’t you?”

“Oh, God! Yes!”

“That’s something we have in common,” Stephanie went on, working her slippery fingers in and out of Tori’s perfect behind, “I didn’t realize it until Mike had ten inches of dick in my ass,” Tori quivered, “but we can both cum from anal sex, and cum like crazy.”


Stephanie pulled her fingers out of Tori’s ass, put the tip of the black dildo to her backdoor, and then made Tori lick her fingers clean as she pushed the head of the toy inside her sister. Tori groaned as the big toy spread her open, wider than she’d ever been. Tori yelped, and Stephanie spanked her perfect ass cheek.

“Oh, Tori,” she said, “I wish you could see this! You’ve got such a great ass, and it looks so good getting opened up like this.”

“Stephie, it hurts!” Tori cried, clutching the sheets.

“I know, baby,” Stephanie cooed, “but it’s going to feel so good once it’s inside.”

She pushed a little more of the toy up her sister’s round bottom, Tori’s whimpers making her wet again.

“Oh, oh, ooooh!” Tori cried, 5 inches of the dildo buried in her rectum.

“That’s my girl,” Stephanie said, “Just relax. You’re going to take the whole thing for Stephie, aren’t you?”

The pain was awful, but Stephanie had been right. As another 2 inches of the toy went into her tiny ass, she started to get accustomed to the fullness, and then it started to feel good.

“Yesss...” Tori hissed.

Stephanie picked up her phone and switched on the camera, holding it with a shaky hand as she worked the toy further into her sister. Tori was groaning nonstop, now, whimpering and shaking. Stephanie pushed a final time, and the full 8 inches of the black toy became fully lodged in Tori’s ass. Tori felt the fake ball sack against her pussy, and she knew that she had taken the whole thing.

“Oh, that’s so good, Tori!” Stephanie said, “8 inches of black cock, all the way inside your asshole. Does that feel good?”

“Ughhh! It’ feels...good!”

“I’ll bet it does! Now, just let Stephie make your ass cum, okay?”

“Oh! Okay!”

Stephanie slowly pulled a few inches of the toy out, spit on Tori’s asshole, and then worked it back in slowly. Tori shivered and shook. She’d never felt so full, so stretched. She wondered how big that fucking toy was. Kyle’s dick had been easy compared to this! Now that Stephanie was pulling it out, and pushing it back in, Tori’s ass began to contract around the invading toy, sucking at it just like her pussy did when she had cock in her.

“I need to tell you something,” Stephanie said, fucking the toy in and out of her sister’s asshole, “I don’t think mom and dad have told you yet, because they’re trying to think of a good way to say it.”

“W... what... are... ugh... you... oh, fuck!” Tori came on the toy in her ass, humping the bed.

“Mmmm, that was a good one! Oh, well, you remember how I told you that I fucked our brother, right? How he put his big dick up my ass and pussy?”

Tori remembered, and the thought set off another orgasm, this one even bigger and better. She was drooling on Stephanie’s bed, her mind trying to focus on what Stephanie was saying, but the big toy up her ass made it hard to think of anything else.

“Well, you’re not the only slut in this family,” Stephanie went on, “Our mother’s a slut. Did you know that? I’m not the only pussy in this house that’s had Mike’s dick in it.”

“Oh, God!” Tori cried, “You... you mean...”

“Yes, our mother’s been fucking Mike’s cock, too. And that’s not all,”

“Ughh! Stephie, I’m cummmming!” Stephanie could see Tori’s little asshole clenching the toy as her sister came for a third time. She let her ride it out for a moment.

“See, I’m a bit of a slut myself,” Stephanie told her, “I’m daddy’s slut.”

“W... what?”

“I’m daddy’s hot little teenage fuck toy, sissy,” Stephanie said, “Daddy put his big prick up my pussy and took my cherry!”

Tori was a blubbering mess now, stuck on a seemingly endless, mind-blowing orgasm that started deep in her ass, and radiated through her whole body. She couldn’t be sure that she’d heard Stephanie right.

“Oh, and mom was there, too,” Stephanie said, “she watched it all, and licked my cunt while daddy fucked me with his foot long cock.”

Tori’s orgasms were growing weaker, but her head spun like crazy. Her eyes were blurry with tears and stars. Her legs had long ago ceased to hold her up. Stephanie held the toy up her ass, but she was no longer moving it. Her sister lay beside her, and let the toy go. Then Stephanie was kissing her, putting her hot tongue in Tori’s mouth. After making out with her for a minute, she pulled her mouth away and stroked Tori’s cheek.

“So, you see, it’s okay that you’re a slut, Tori. Now you fit in with the rest of us.”

“Is...” Tori swallowed hard, tried to catch her breath as her asshole slowly pushed the toy out, “Is any of that...true?”

“Every word,” Stephanie confirmed.

“You fucked our whole family?” Tori said, trying to grasp the reality.

“Well, technically, Mike and dad fucked me, but it’s all the same in the end.”

“Mom and Mike...”

“Fucking like rabbits,” Stephanie said, “Although, now we’re going to have to share that big dick of his with Cindy, who is really quite sweet, by the way. Dumb as a rock, yes, but a good girl.”

The toy finally fell free of Tori’s ass, and she felt very empty. Her asshole was wide open, and she could feel the cool air of Stephanie’s room blowing through it, cooling her heated insides. She couldn’t believe she’d just let Stephanie shove that thing in her ass, but moreover, she couldn’t believe how hard it had made her cum.

“That felt good, didn’t it?” Stephanie asked.

“Yes,” Tori had to admit.

“Well, now that we got you opened up, it’s time for your next present!” Stephanie cried excitedly.

“What?” Tori said, flushed.

Stephanie picked up the other item from the bag, and before Tori could protest, Stephanie pushed the round butt plug into her stretched asshole.

“Ughhh! Oh, God!” Tori cried, “What the fuck, Stephie!”

Stephanie laughed, and smacked her sister’s ass, “Oh, calm down. It’s just a little butt plug.”


“Well, I want to make sure it doesn’t hurt so bad when I get Mike to put his big prick up your ass, too!”

“But, Stephie, I don’t want Mike to fuck my ass!” Tori complained.

“Don’t be such a whiner, Tori,” Stephanie said, sitting in front of her sister’s face and spreading her legs, “Things have changed a little in this family, while you were away, and I want to make sure you’re fitting in. I’m doing this for you,” she said.

Fucking Tori’s ass had made her incredibly horny again, and when she pushed her hot cunt against Tori’s flushed face, her sister didn’t object. She lapped away at Stephanie’s slit for her like the good pussy girl she was.

“Besides, we can’t have you out there just fucking random college boys in dressing rooms, can we?”


“Tori, don’t talk with your mouth full of cunt,” Stephanie said, grabbing her sister’s beautiful blonde hair and rubbing her slit against her face, “No, I’d much rather you were being fucked in a nice, safe environment, like home. And believe me, once Mike’s big cock is all the way up that little ass of yours, you’ll not only be my little pussy girl, but we’ll also make you a real butt slut for your big brother. Now, make me cum, bitch!”

Tori still couldn’t understand why all the sick things that vomited out of her sister’s mouth made her so hot, but they did. The plug in her ass had ceased to hurt, and had given her that nice, full feeling she’d experienced while the toy had been in her. The way that Stephanie was using her face to get off, was also doing a number on the confused teenager’s mind.

She should be revolted. She should be fighting. Instead, she was sucking Stephanie’s pussy like a little bitch, and wondering if Mike’s cock would make her cum even better than the toy. She was such a stupid slut!

“You know,” Stephanie mused, “since you’re getting such big orgasms from being ass fucked, I wonder if we should even chance taking that belt of yours off again. Sure, you’ll need to wash your cunt, and all, but we don’t want a repeat of today with you fingering your cunt. And we certainly don’t need some strange college guys shoving their dicks up your little teen pussy all the time. Let me think about that.”

That made Tori stop licking, and she pulled her mouth from her sister’s cunt in horror.

“No! You can’t, Stephie, please!”

“Well, if you keep being a good sister, maybe I won’t. But if you’re going to fight me about Mike getting his dick up your ass, well...” she let the threat hang in the air.

Tori redoubled her efforts on Stephanie’s pussy, determined to be the best pussy slut she could be. The thought of staying in the belt for the next two months, unable to touch her pussy or have it fucked was too awful to think about. If that meant she had to take Mike’s cock in her ass, then she was going to do it, and she was going to cum. Stephanie held her hair tightly and came on her face.


Enjoying this story? You can own the entire Hamlin family epic, a sprawling 55-chapter tale of betrayal, jealousy, and finding forgiveness. This book spans 658 pages of family fuckery, a roller coaster of emotion that, after eight years, still stands as one of the most loved and best-selling works in my library.

If you're looking for more family fun stories, check out the recommended reading:

Tempting Trevor: A masterclass in sibling seduction, this story follows Stacy's manipulation of her naïve brother and his girlfriend.

Correcting Kelly: A premium read, this dark tale is a spiral into a wicked plot by an unhinged father, to remake his family. Follow the evil Todd as changes his spoiled wife into a mindless sex pet, wholly focused on his cock, while simultaneously replacing her in his bed with his daughter, Kelly, turning her into his personal breeding slut.

Need more Hamlin twins? Read A Hamlin Family Interlude, a follow-up story that takes place between The Second Place Sister and Doppelgänger.

Fancy some further sibling exploitation? Follow the bi-weekly adventures of Lucy and Rachel, an unfolding story that follows Lucy's depraved lessons in "the right way" to masturbate in Gooner Girl.

Need something a little shorter? Consider the short story collection Horrible Households: Tales of Incestuous Exploitation!

Need some visual stimulation? Bookmark the post The Illustrated Sister, where I post commissioned artwork for this story as it becomes available.

If you prefer willing submission with a rape kink twist, you can read about Sasha and her twisted fantasy, which becomes all-too real, in Sasha's Obsession.

If you prefer to own the whole dirty family collection, you can grab the Family Fun Pack

905 views0 comments

Related Posts


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page